Why Elon Musk’s Starlink Rs 4,200 a month ($50) Faces an Uphill Battle Against Airtel and Jio in India

Why Elon Musk’s Starlink Rs 4,200 a month ($50) Faces an Uphill Battle Against Airtel and Jio in India

Starlink satellite internet has left the world in shock, but not India at least for Reliance Jio and Bharti Airtel. The global appeal of Starlink resonates well beyond geography; however, entering into India poses serious handicapping critical challenges – regulatory hurdles, pricing anxiety, and the unique contours of rural internet in India.

Pricing: A Major Roadblock.

The biggest problem with Starlink is also its pricing, which is totally out of the pocket of most Indian users. Starlink’s service costs Rs 4,200 a month ($50), which can’t even compete with local competition. In India, Airtel Xstream Fiber and Reliance JioFiber begin at Rs 499 and Rs 399 per month, respectively. This price gap is a deterring factor as India is still a country that provides some of the lowest cost access to the internet globally.

Additionally, with 5G services now opening up along all the country’s length and breadth, both rural and urban consumers are being exposed to 100 Mbps speed at prices that are substantially lower. For the price-sensitive rural customer – the customer target for Starlink – the cost of a satellite internet connection simply does not add up when one is able to get cheaper terrestrial options from Jio and Airtel.

Regulatory Headwinds: The Licensing Labyrinth

Even if Starlink manages to achieve the price parity, regulatory issues would be a problem for it in India. Spectrum allocation for satellite communications becomes quite more tougher and complicated here compared to others in the world. This is mainly because telecom regulations are much more complicated in India.

Starlink would require Unified Access Service Licence (UASL) in India to operate the services over there. This encompasses one license for all forms of telecommunications services, of which satellite communications fall in that pot. This is not an easy thing to get; there are numerous requirements still left, including those on specific rollout obligations, quality standards, and the contribution operators are supposed to make towards government revenues through fees in licensing. Whether Starlink would succeed or fail in the Indian market would largely depend on its ability to cut through this regulatory landscape.

Another contentious issue that emerged was the question of allocation of spectrum. Reliance Jio is in favor of a full-fledged auction for satellite spectrum and feels that it creates a level playing field for all the telecom players. Bharti Airtel and its partners, including OneWeb, have preferred administrative allocation with a less competitive approach. India’s Telecom Minister Jyotiraditya Scindia hinted that there is an administrative plan with fair pricing regimes in place and appears well-aligned with the views of Airtel on the matter.

Starlink’s prospects will depend on how this debate is resolved and whether the regulatory framework will permit the entry of such a company, if at all. Market Dynamics: Airtel, Jio, and India’s Rural Density

The third major challenge that Starlink faces in India is a unique market dynamics, particularly in rural installations. A third major challenge that Starlink faces in India is a unique market dynamics, particularly in rural installations. While most sparsely populated regions overseas are fertile ground for Starlink to grow, villages in rural India give an entirely different picture by dint of their relatively high population concentration in those villages. The cost-benefit analysis of the service does not make sense if one compares them with relatively affordable 5G services gaining ground in these districts.

India’s two big telecom players, Airtel and Reliance Jio, already have cornered a huge chunk in the urban as well as rural markets. OneWeb’s tie-up further garrisons Airtel’s advantage in the satellite internet market with ground stations already set up in states like Gujarat and Tamil Nadu. This gives Airtel less chary of facing any competition from Starlink. In fact, Airtel has been quite aggressive in positioning itself to serve those markets that Starlink would target, thus giving it a prime competitive advantage.

In this space, Reliance Jio is another market leader, especially with the thrust from the firm in the 5G space. In infrastructure and customer base, it can equate to anything coming into this space, even Starlink. More importantly, the firm continues its thrust in the rural areas which Starlink had hoped it would be its entry point. All these points weaken the argument for the satellite operator.

The Spectrum Debate: Approaches diverge but the prize remains the same

That is interesting in the Starlink vs. Jio and Airtel battle: it has sparked a raging debate over spectrum allocation. Now while Reliance Jio advocates an auction-based approach, Airtel favors administrative allocation with fair pricing set by the telecom regulator. Difference of opinion thus reveals that both are warming up to a battle that the likely inroad of satellite services is going to have into the mass Indian market.

This is yet another reason the Indian government supports administrative allocation: it follows international practices and offers companies like Airtel a great strategic advantage. Musk himself claims to boast of the Indian government’s decision, stating that an auction for satellite spectrum would be unprecedented since the ITU assigns such spectrum for shared satellite use.

Still, the success of Starlink in India is still something not too sure with the support of administrative allocation by the government. Not that regulatory decisions are going to normalize the balance sheet of the Indian market where Starlink has its name sported; at best, it can do some equity to make things even.

Airtel is one who teamed up with OneWeb for satellite communications and has a very good standing in Satcom.

Airtel already has a good track record in the satellite communications market in India as it is one of OneWeb’s partners. It already has all operational ground stations, and by default, is well-positioned to address both urban and rural markets. The service from OneWeb isn’t just about internet but the infrastructure that will then help fuel growth; Airtel is well placed to find comfort at the top of the satcom heap.

It is this underlying infrastructure which places Airtel on a much stronger footing as a comparison with Starlink, especially as the Indian government is persistently designing policies that encourage administrative allocation. Further, besides the strength of OneWeb in satellite internet services, Airtel already runs quite far ahead of Starlink by quite a few strides with preparedness in both market and local partners.

Conclusion: Why No One Fears Starlink in India

While Elon Musk’s Starlink makes all the noises in the rest of the world, in India, the company faces a plethora of big problems. Starting with pricing issues, including regulatory hurdles and a competitive landscape dominated by Airtel and Reliance Jio, Starlink would find it incredibly hard to enter into India.

For the time being, this latest satellite venture by Musk barely seems to just graze both Airtel and Jio. They are more than adequately geared up for fending off this fresh competition from Starlink with the groundwork already laid out through existing infrastructure, local expertise, and supportive government policies. While it does have massive potential for such underserved areas in the country, reality cannot be more stingy when it comes to this India telecom market.
Read More At Here

Disclaimer:

All above recommendations are of the market analysts. Neither the author, nor the brokerage firm, nor Stockstoday.in will be responsible for any loss arising out of any such decision taken based upon this information. All users are cautioned to take their own expert advice prior to making any investment decision.

Web Stories
India’s gig economy:
India’s gig economy:
India’s gig economy: